Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander · 2024 Commander precon
Endless Punishment upgrade guide
Budget upgrades, cuts and the full decklist for Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls.
Endless Punishment is a Rakdos (black-red) Commander precon from Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander (2024), led by Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls. Out of the box it runs 38 lands, 9 ramp pieces, 16 card-draw effects, 10 removal spells and 3 board wipes, with an average mana value of 3.49.
Measured against a typical Commander build, it's lightest on ramp, and 8 of its lands enter tapped. Its game plan leans on lifegain, so the plan below favors cards that push that. The $50 plan below makes 10 swaps for $39.56.
Deck health
$50 budget plan
Best upgrades for Endless Punishment
10 swaps for $39.56, built around lifegain. Prices as of November 6, 2026.
Add 10
Protection: deck has 1 of ~2 · #12 on EDHREC$1.89
Ramp: deck has 9 of ~10 · #55 on EDHREC$0.20
Fits your Lifegain plan · #1,092 on EDHREC$0.19
Fits your Lifegain plan · #488 on EDHREC$10.10
Fits your Lifegain plan · #1,119 on EDHREC$1.56
Proven staple in your colors · #34 on EDHREC$0.25
Proven staple in your colors · #38 on EDHREC$4.90
Untapped land for all your colors · #67 on EDHREC$8.72
Untapped land for all your colors · #221 on EDHREC$0.26
Untapped land for all your colors · #94 on EDHREC$11.49
Cut 10
Enters tapped — slows your early turns
Enters tapped — slows your early turns
Enters tapped — slows your early turns
Trims you to 36 lands — the deck runs 38
Trims you to 36 lands — the deck runs 38
Costs 8 mana · Extra removal: deck already has 10 (~8 is plenty)
Costs 6 mana · Doesn't support the deck's plan
Costs 7 mana · Extra removal: deck already has 10 (~8 is plenty)
Costs 6 mana · Extra card draw: deck already has 16 (~10 is plenty)
Doesn't support the deck's plan
Endless Punishment decklist
Commander (1)
- 1Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls$24.71
Creatures (32)
- 1Barbflare Gremlin$0.36
- 1Blood Artist$3.74
- 1Blood Seeker$0.37
- 1Braids, Arisen Nightmare$4.44
- 1Brash Taunter$3.99
- 1Combustible Gearhulk$0.35
- 1Falkenrath Noble$0.30
- 1Fate Unraveler$3.18
- 1Fear of Burning Alive$0.28
- 1Florian, Voldaren Scion$0.48
- 1Gleeful Arsonist$6.84
- 1Gray Merchant of Asphodel$4.59
- 1Harsh Mentor$0.36
- 1Kaervek the Merciless$0.36
- 1Kardur, Doomscourge$3.37
- 1Kederekt Parasite$8.14
- 1Massacre Girl$0.50
- 1Massacre Wurm$4.63
- 1Mayhem Devil$0.60
- 1Mogis, God of Slaughter$5.69
- 1Morbid Opportunist$0.37
- 1Nightshade Harvester$0.71
- 1Persistent Constrictor$13.56
- 1Rakdos, Lord of Riots$2.06
- 1Rampaging Ferocidon$2.05
- 1Solemn Simulacrum$0.30
- 1Star Athlete$1.25
- 1Stormfist Crusader$1.09
- 1Syr Konrad, the Grim$1.57
- 1Tectonic Giant$0.34
- 1The Lord of Pain$10.66
- 1Vial Smasher the Fierce$3.38
Instants (6)
- 1Bedevil$0.64
- 1Blood Pact$0.29
- 1Chaos Warp$0.48
- 1Infernal Grasp$0.33
- 1Rakdos Charm$3.63
- 1Suspended Sentence$1.07
Sorceries (7)
- 1Blasphemous Act$1.01
- 1Decree of Pain$0.34
- 1Feed the Swarm$0.27
- 1Grab the Prize$0.38
- 1Light Up the Stage$0.36
- 1Sadistic Shell Game$0.60
- 1Sign in Blood$4.16
Artifacts (11)
- 1Arcane Signet$0.68
- 1Basilisk Collar$4.57
- 1Fellwar Stone$1.48
- 1Lightning Greaves$4.91
- 1Mask of Griselbrand$0.83
- 1Mind Stone$0.34
- 1Rakdos Signet$3.80
- 1Séance Board$3.39
- 1Sol Ring$2.09
- 1Talisman of Indulgence$3.39
- 1Thought Vessel$2.90
Enchantments (5)
- 1Bastion of Remembrance$0.38
- 1Enchanter's Bane$0.32
- 1Spiked Corridor // Torture Pit$9.53
- 1Spiteful Visions$1.34
- 1Theater of Horrors$0.38
Lands (38)
- 1Ash Barrens$0.24
- 1Blackcleave Cliffs$2.31
- 1Bloodfell Caves$0.29
- 1Canyon Slough$0.23
- 1Command Tower$0.35
- 1Dragonskull Summit$0.69
- 1Evolving Wilds$0.26
- 1Exotic Orchard$0.21
- 1Foreboding Ruins$0.38
- 1Geothermal Bog$0.31
- 1Graven Cairns$5.03
- 1Leechridden Swamp$1.20
- 4Mountain$0.26
- 4Mountain$0.26
- 1Shadowblood Ridge$0.45
- 1Shivan Gorge$1.14
- 1Smoldering Marsh$0.33
- 1Spinerock Knoll$2.29
- 1Sulfurous Springs$3.68
- 4Swamp$0.24
- 4Swamp$0.21
- 1Tainted Peak$1.64
- 1Temple of Malice$0.33
- 1Temple of the False God$0.32
- 1Terramorphic Expanse$0.20
- 1Witch's Clinic$12.21
FAQ
How much is the Endless Punishment precon worth?
At current prices the 100 cards in Endless Punishment are worth about $206.48 as singles (cheapest printings, TCGplayer market price as of November 6, 2026).
What are the best budget upgrades for Endless Punishment?
For about $39.56, our top picks are Swiftfoot Boots, Commander's Sphere, Marauding Blight-Priest, Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose, Well of Lost Dreams. The full 10-card plan with cuts is above, and the upgrade tool can rebuild it for any budget.
What should I cut from Endless Punishment?
Start with Leechridden Swamp, Geothermal Bog, Bloodfell Caves, Spinerock Knoll. These are the least-played or slowest cards that don't support the deck's plan.
More from Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander
$90
Art: Andrey Kuzinskiy
$102
Art: Mila Pesic
$106
Art: David Palumbo
Get new upgrade guides first
One short email when a new Commander precon lands, with its budget upgrade guide. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.