Fallout · 2024 Commander precon
Mutant Menace upgrade guide
Budget upgrades, cuts and the full decklist for The Wise Mothman.
Mutant Menace is a Sultai (blue-black-green) Commander precon from Fallout (2024), led by The Wise Mothman. Out of the box it runs 39 lands, 10 ramp pieces, 11 card-draw effects, 5 removal spells and 1 board wipe, with an average mana value of 3.55.
Measured against a typical Commander build, it's lightest on board wipes and removal, and 9 of its lands enter tapped. Its game plan leans on +1/+1 counters and mutant tribal, so the plan below favors cards that push that. The $50 plan below makes 10 swaps for $37.84.
Deck health
$50 budget plan
Best upgrades for Mutant Menace
10 swaps for $37.84, built around +1/+1 counters and mutant tribal. Prices as of November 6, 2026.
Add 10
Protection: deck has 0 of ~2 · #12 on EDHREC$1.89
Board wipes: deck has 1 of ~3 · #66 on EDHREC$5.47
Protection: deck has 0 of ~2 · #13 on EDHREC$3.88
Removal: deck has 5 of ~8 · #16 on EDHREC$2.18
Fits your +1/+1 counters plan · #944 on EDHREC$0.29
Fits your Mutant tribal plan$1.81
Fits your +1/+1 counters plan · #419 on EDHREC$5.46
Untapped land for black & blue · #49 on EDHREC$4.47
Untapped land for green & blue · #61 on EDHREC$6.45
Untapped land for black & green · #71 on EDHREC$5.94
Cut 10
Enters tapped — slows your early turns
Enters tapped — slows your early turns
Enters tapped — slows your early turns
Trims you to 36 lands — the deck runs 39
Trims you to 36 lands — the deck runs 39
Rarely played (#8,736 on EDHREC) · Extra card draw: deck already has 11 (~10 is plenty)
Doesn't support the deck's plan
Rarely played (#11,923 on EDHREC) · Costs 12 mana
Doesn't support the deck's plan
Extra card draw: deck already has 11 (~10 is plenty)
Mutant Menace decklist
Commander (1)
- 1The Wise Mothman$1.60
Creatures (28)
- 1Agent Frank Horrigan$2.89
- 1Alpha Deathclaw$1.28
- 1Bloatfly Swarm$1.02
- 1Cathedral Acolyte$0.53
- 1Corpsejack Menace$0.55
- 1Feral Ghoul$1.65
- 1Glowing One$1.34
- 1Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor$1.14
- 1Harold and Bob, First Numens$0.31
- 1Infesting Radroach$0.74
- 1Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet$0.39
- 1Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma$0.38
- 1Lumbering Megasloth$0.32
- 1Marcus, Mutant Mayor$0.46
- 1Mirelurk Queen$1.25
- 1Nightkin Ambusher$0.33
- 1Piper Wright, Publick Reporter$0.36
- 1Rampaging Yao Guai$6.25
- 1Raul, Trouble Shooter$0.61
- 1Screeching Scorchbeast$1.35
- 1Strong, the Brutish Thespian$0.36
- 1Tato Farmer$0.45
- 1The Master, Transcendent$0.52
- 1Tireless Tracker$0.37
- 1Vexing Radgull$0.51
- 1Watchful Radstag$0.99
- 1Winding Constrictor$0.43
- 1Young Deathclaws$0.33
Instants (7)
- 1Atomize$5.56
- 1Biomass Mutation$0.23
- 1Contaminated Drink$0.38
- 1Inspiring Call$0.59
- 1Mutational Advantage$5.53
- 1Putrefy$0.35
- 1Radstorm$4.26
Sorceries (7)
- 1Casualties of War$0.32
- 1Cultivate$0.47
- 1Farseek$1.20
- 1Find // Finality$0.28
- 1Harmonize$0.34
- 1Nuclear Fallout$2.44
- 1Rampant Growth$0.61
Artifacts (10)
- 1Arcane Signet$0.67
- 1Contagion Clasp$0.37
- 1Nuka-Nuke Launcher$0.37
- 1Power Fist$9.83
- 1Recon Craft Theta$1.12
- 1Sol Ring$2.02
- 1Strength Bobblehead$3.47
- 1Talisman of Curiosity$0.51
- 1Talisman of Dominance$1.06
- 1Talisman of Resilience$0.44
Enchantments (8)
- 1Branching Evolution$7.83
- 1Fraying Sanity$0.51
- 1Guardian Project$11.61
- 1Hardened Scales$2.61
- 1Inexorable Tide$2.88
- 1Struggle for Project Purity$3.12
- 1Vault 12: The Necropolis$0.38
- 1Vault 87: Forced Evolution$0.29
Lands (39)
- 1Ash Barrens$0.27
- 1Command Tower$0.40
- 1Darkwater Catacombs$0.37
- 1Drowned Catacomb$1.28
- 1Evolving Wilds$0.26
- 1Exotic Orchard$0.36
- 1Fetid Pools$0.30
- 3Forest$0.39
- 2Forest$0.35
- 1Hinterland Harbor$0.46
- 3Island$0.27
- 2Island$0.31
- 1Mariposa Military Base$0.40
- 1Mortuary Mire$0.41
- 1Nesting Grounds$0.33
- 1Opulent Palace$0.41
- 1Overflowing Basin$0.63
- 1Path of Ancestry$0.28
- 1Sunken Hollow$0.39
- 3Swamp$0.53
- 2Swamp$0.43
- 1Tainted Isle$2.81
- 1Tainted Wood$0.39
- 1Temple of Deceit$0.35
- 1Temple of Malady$0.34
- 1Temple of Mystery$0.29
- 1Temple of the False God$0.28
- 1Terramorphic Expanse$0.31
- 1Viridescent Bog$0.29
- 1Woodland Cemetery$0.87
FAQ
How much is the Mutant Menace precon worth?
At current prices the 100 cards in Mutant Menace are worth about $118.59 as singles (cheapest printings, TCGplayer market price as of November 6, 2026).
What are the best budget upgrades for Mutant Menace?
For about $37.84, our top picks are Swiftfoot Boots, Toxic Deluge, Lightning Greaves, Counterspell, Evolution Witness. The full 10-card plan with cuts is above, and the upgrade tool can rebuild it for any budget.
What should I cut from Mutant Menace?
Start with Fetid Pools, Mortuary Mire, Opulent Palace, Temple of Malady. These are the least-played or slowest cards that don't support the deck's plan.
More from Fallout
Get new upgrade guides first
One short email when a new Commander precon lands, with its budget upgrade guide. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.